THE WTO MINISTERIAL MEET 2022: DEVELOPING COUNTRIES' VOICES UNHEARD
The four-day Ministerial Conference started at WTO headquarters in GENEVA Switzerland on Sunday 12th June 2022. This type of meeting is held every four-year to find some consensus among the various trading member countries. Negotiators from 162 nations sought to have convergence on a range of issues including WTO’s response to future pandemics and an IP waiver for vaccines, fisheries subsidies, WTO reforms, agriculture, food security, and e-commerce.
India's Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal was the man in the spotlight at the WTO's 12th gathering of trade ministers(MC12).
In order to have concessions on different issues, the meet was extended for one more day, that is, Thursday16th June. Everybody at the conference was hopeful that some positivity on issues will emerge at the end of the 5th extended day.
FISHING SUBSIDIES & NON-SPECIFIC FUEL SUBSCIDIES:
INDIA and many other countries sought an end to the ban imposed on fishing subsidies being given by developing countries for 25 years allowing only a transition period of 7 years. These countries also sought to put an end to non-specific fuel subsidies or those that are not targeted at a particular industry, such as those given by the US and European Union to transport and water sports that lead to illegal, unregulated, and uncontrolled fishing globally.
India wanted that developing countries not engaged in distant water fishing, beyond 200 nautical miles from the seashores of the country, should be exempt from fishing subsidy prohibitions for 25 years. Subsidies for fisheries in India include a sales tax rebate on diesel, financial assistance during a fishing ban, assistance for the purchase of new nets and boats, life-saving jackets, and navigation systems besides the development of marine infrastructure. The draft agreement proposed that 'A developing country member may grant or maintain subsidies to fishing and fishing-related activities within its exclusive economic zone or area of competence of a relevant RFMO/A for a maximum of seven years after the entry into force up to 2030.'
Moreover, subsidies granted or maintained would be exempt from actions for two additional years after the end of the period, similar to the peace clause developing countries have for agricultural subsidies. Proposed that the developing countries may also give subsidies for low-income, resource-poor, and livelihood fishing or fishing-related activities, up to 12 or 24 nautical miles measured from the baselines.
Indian Marine Fishermen Population also opposed the draft. This population in India is more than the marine fishermen population of 112 countries. As per the Marine Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute Census 2016 the total marine fishermen population is 3.77 million comprising 0.90 million families of which 67.3% population was below poverty line.
Traditional fisheries involve fishing households using relatively small amounts of capital and small fishing vessels usually about 20 meters in overall length making short trips close to the shores. Most Indian Fishermen live below the poverty line. If subsidies are stopped, their lives and livelihood will be endangered. Subsidies should be stopped for industrial fishing and not for small fishermen.
THE PRIVATE SECTOR'S ENTRY INTO WTO PROPOSED
It was for the first time that the draft outcome documents issued by thal WTO sought to pave the way for the formal entry of the private sector into multilateral trade talks as proposed by the European Union last year. Developing countries like India and South Africa opposed it as this would allow private companies a high seat at the WTO negotiating table and influence processes and outcomes.
The draft outcome text on pandemic response also takes note of the work done by the WTO Secretariat, including in collaboration with other international organizations relating to covid-19. These international organizations refer to the private sector which the EU has been pursuing. Any formal role for the private sector would cause grave asymmetry in the global trade talks as many governments would find it difficult to negotiate freely. India has opposed giving any overseeing role to the General Council in the reform process of the WTO.
India, Pakistan, Cuba, and 44 other countries of the African group came together seeking a moratorium on trade measures and providing sufficient flexibilities on intellectual property disciplines for developing countries to fight the Covid-19 pandemic. Developing countries should not be asked to relinquish their trade policy of permanent liberalization of tariffs or use of export restrictions. Such a moratorium should be for the duration of the pandemic for government actions to fight the pandemic.
The scope of the moratorium should also extend to e-commerce transmissions for predictability of business, trade, and industry. Developing and less developing countries are keen to levy customs duty on e-commerce transactions and willing to use tariffs to support domestic industries. These countries firmly stated that Special & Differential Treatment(S&DT) was a treaty-embedded, non-negotiable right of the developing countries.
The WTO was a forum that was never conceptualized to change the economic models of members. The US and EU and other countries are trying to bring in non-trade issues in trade negotiations to address social and economic matters. The reform process must support poor nations' access to affordable medicines and medical technologies vis-a-vis traditional knowledge.
SEEKING HIGHER FOOD PRODUCTION AND PRICE STABILITY:
On the penultimate day of negotiations, India along with 46 developing and least develop developed countries pushed for enhancing production and maintaining food price stability. The countries as a part of G-33 also insisted on maintaining an open and predictable agricultural trade to ensure the continued flow of food and agricultural products. Global food prices are rising and there is a need to ensure public stockholding for food for all.
The G-33 African group and ACP (African, Caribean, and Pacific) group had already submitted a joint proposal suggesting a permanent solution for public stockholding that should account for inflation and the price based on recent reference price rather than old base of 1986-88. They also suggested a new methodology to calculate the subsidies either accounting for "accessive inflation" in the External Reference Price(ERP) or calculating the ERP based on the last five years excluding the highest and lowest entry for that product. ERP is the average price based on the base years 1986-88 which has not been revised for years. The G-33 emphasized that a universal, rules-based, open, non-discriminatory, equitable, and WTO-centered multilateral trading system is vital for global agricultural trade. India must ensure that decisions in the WTO are compatible with multilateral climate agreements also. The biggest economies have announced their intention to a net-zero economy. India too has set this goal by 2070. Trade can't be insulated from the impact of greenhouse gas emissions.
SPECTACULAR SUCCESS ACHIEVED AT THE MC12
The Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal spoke on June 17 that India has achieved spectacular success at the World Trade Organization(WTO's) Ministerial Conference(MC12)in Geneva, Switzerland. Mr. Goyal had led India's delegation to the WTO at the four-day global summit which was extended for two additional days due to intense negotiations.
Round-the-clock negotiations among 162 delegates produced the "Geneva Package" confirming a historical achievement for the multilateral trading system. The package contains a series of unprecedented decisions on fisheries subsidies, WTO response to emergencies, including a waiver of certain requirements concerning compulsory licensing for COVID-19 vaccines, food safety, and agriculture, and WTO reform.
India was successful in ensuring the livelihood of its farmers and fishermen. All participants at the MC12 were convinced in allowing a patent waiver for the manufacturing of Covid Vaccines. This conference has reestablished the positions of multilateral institutions by deciding the issues which were pending for many decades.
The agreement on fisheries is currently limited to illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing. The discussions on subsidies will continue. Currently, there are no restrictions on government subsidies. The WTO has taken cognizance of India's demand for regulating illegal deep fishing.
There is no negative outcome for India's agriculture sector. India's public stockholding program for foodgrains will continue unhindered. On the issue of food- security talks are going on. There is no curb on foodgrain exports to the World Food Program which seeks to fight hunger in places hit by conflicts, disasters, and climate change.